AI coding agents compared: Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Pi and Oh My Pi
description: "Eight coding agents compared on terminal editing, browser debugging, model choice and pull requests. Includes Pi vs. Oh My Pi vs. OpenCode and where each fits." date: 2026-11-21 lang: en slug: best-ai-coding-agents-compared
AI coding agents compared: Claude Code, Codex, Cursor and Pi
Flavio Copes gave three terminal agents a small bookmark-search bug. The function paginated its results before removing archived bookmarks. Ask for one result when the first match was archived and you'd get an empty page, even with a perfectly good match sitting one row down. OpenCode and Codex CLI both fixed it. Claude Code stopped at sign-in on his machine. The two successful runs used different models. Copes published the fixture, so anyone who cares about a particular setup can try it on the same JavaScript. The test and the code
A terminal and a test runner are plenty for that job. A customer who can't tap the checkout button on a phone presents a different problem. The repository may look fine until somebody opens the page at the right width, with the cookie banner still on screen.
Claude Code and Codex
Claude Code is a good fit for the part of debugging you spend asking questions. In the bookmark example, one question matters before anyone edits the filter: does the API's total count archived records, and which clients rely on that number? Claude Code can trace the call sites, use a subagent for a separate investigation, and wait in plan mode while you settle the expected behavior. Its checkpoints let you rewind tracked file edits. Anything that happened outside those files, such as a database write, needs its own recovery procedure. Claude Code guide · What checkpoints cover
Codex CLI is equally at home in a terminal. The desktop app is particularly handy when an unrelated ticket arrives halfway through your own changes. Say the homepage is open with uncommitted edits and an old product URL needs a redirect. Give Codex a Git worktree off the appropriate branch and the redirect gets its own checkout and diff. When testing the second instance, check which database it connects to and which port it listens on. Separate directories can still point at the same service. Codex CLI · Desktop worktrees
If you already pay for ChatGPT or Claude, try the included client on a familiar bug before adding a subscription. Check which credentials it picked up. Claude Code can use an Anthropic API key from the environment and bill the API account. Codex's allowance depends in part on the model, reasoning setting and amount of work in the session. Two monthly prices tell you little about the cost of maintaining a particular repository. Claude subscription access · Codex usage
Pi, Oh My Pi and OpenCode
Pi is Mario Zechner's open-source terminal coding agent, now maintained at Earendil. The current npm package is @earendil-works/pi-coding-agent and the command is still pi. You can switch models mid-session, add a command or tool in TypeScript and load it with /reload. Some early write-ups say Pi has no MCP support. Version 1.0 added native MCP support through Codemode. Pi · Package rename · 1.0 release notes
Pi's session tree is a good reason to try it even if you're happy with your current model. Armin Ronacher built a /review extension that branches into a fresh context, inspects the patch for things he cares about, including new dependencies, then brings the findings back to the coding session. He also wrote /answer to gather questions scattered throughout an agent's response into one place where he could answer them. Those are small, personal annoyances. Pi lets you change the client that causes them. Ronacher's account and extensions
Drydock measured another difference by pointing Pi and Claude Code at the same mock API with the same repository and model ID. Pi 1.5.0's first request body was 5,977 characters. Claude Code 2.1.318 sent 86,184. Much of the difference came from tool definitions and instructions. No model answered either request. The measurement says something useful about what each client puts in context on startup, but it gives you neither a token bill nor a code-quality score. Request captures and test conditions
Oh My Pi, invoked as omp, is a separate fork maintained by Stencil Labs. It ships a language-server integration, subagents and several editing modes. Moving a TypeScript file that's re-exported through several modules is a case where access to the language server pays off. Its hashline editor also ties a patch to lines in a particular snapshot. If the file has changed since the agent read it, the editor can recover the edit when the location is unambiguous or send back the current context. That matters on a branch where someone else is editing the same file. Oh My Pi repository · Edit tool specification
OpenCode also lets you keep a terminal client while changing providers. Its agent definitions and permission rules come ready to configure. To give several repositories a read-only reviewer, define the agent, limit its tools and choose its model. I'd start with OpenCode for that setup. I'd use upstream Pi if I wanted to write my own review command and change how the results appear in the session. Oh My Pi makes more sense if I want code navigation and snapshot-checked edits available from the start. OpenCode agents · Providers · Permissions
One more Pi name turns up in searches. Pi Durable was introduced as an experimental developer package for agents that need to survive a process restart. A tool that looks up an issue can declare itself safe to replay. An interrupted deployment can instead leave a record for the agent to inspect before doing anything else. For interactive coding on a laptop, the Pi CLI is the package to install. Pi Durable design
Cursor and Google Antigravity
Cursor's cloud agents can run the application and return a browser recording, screenshots and logs. For the checkout complaint, specify a 375-pixel viewport, a long product name and a fresh session that still shows the cookie banner. Ask the agent to click the button. A screenshot taken after dismissing the banner can make a broken checkout look immaculate. Remote testing also needs enough fixture data to reach the affected screen. Cursor computer use · Cloud environment setup
Greg Baugues did a useful controlled comparison in 2025: he used Claude 3.7 Sonnet in both Cursor and Claude Code for three tasks on a production app. He preferred Claude Code's terminal interface, yet reported that Cursor's documentation search helped it get unstuck. The comparison is dated. Holding the model constant is still a useful way to find out how much the editor and its tools contribute. Baugues' comparison and demo
Google Antigravity puts more emphasis on reviewing the implementation plan. For a change that spans carts, checkout and analytics, Planning Mode with Request Review gives you somewhere to flag “preserve discount codes on existing carts” before the agent touches the code. Its Orchestrator can use Gemini 4 Neon to plan and Hydrogen to make scoped edits and run tests. I'd skip the formal plan for a CSS fix. It's useful on a checkout migration where two developers could reasonably disagree on the order of operations. Plan review settings · Neon and Hydrogen in Antigravity
GitHub Copilot cloud agent
For teams that assign issues and review code in GitHub, Copilot's cloud agent keeps the patch, CI results and discussion on the pull request. Agent Merge can watch an existing PR for failed checks or merge conflicts. There's a practical wrinkle for solo maintainers: if the repository requires an approving review, the person who prompted Copilot can't supply the required approval on that PR. Check who else can approve it before handing the queue over. Copilot PR review · Agent Merge
Public PR data tells you more when it's broken down by task. A study covering 7,156 pull requests found 82.1% acceptance for documentation changes and 66.1% for features. A tool given more documentation tickets starts with a considerable advantage in an overall table. The sample had just 139 Claude Code PRs and included neither Pi nor Oh My Pi. It offers little basis for ranking today's eight products against one another. Study and task breakdown
For a website with a steady queue of visual bugs, I'd trial Cursor first. For parallel fixes with a reliable local reproduction, I'd start with Codex worktrees. Terminal users have a closer choice: Pi if you want to keep your own commands and extensions for years, Oh My Pi if you want the editor machinery supplied, OpenCode if configuring permissions and switching providers covers most of what you need. A bug you already understand will tell you more about any of them than eight freshly generated homepages.
Updated November 21, 2026. Comparative tests are attributed to the developers who ran them.